home » blog » From Paper to Laptop and Back to … iPad

Closer is Better >> Nearsoft Blog

Matt Perez

From Paper to Laptop and Back to … iPad

Posted by Matt Perez on 05/28/2011 in tablet , reading , paper , kindle , ipad

I used to love reading on paper–its smell, the texture, easy on the eyes, etc. Then switched to reading most everything on my desktop/laptop. Now I find that I don't like "looking up" to my screen to read anymore and I much prefer reading on my iPad–which fits in the same space that paper used to occupy.

Kindle DX and iPad

Note for Kindle Lovers

Yes, the Kindle feels even more like paper and not only because of its reflective display technology but its weight, insignificant power consumption, etc. However, today's "paper" also has to let me browse the web, run apps, support color and touch/gestures, etc. Unfortunately, the Kindle is brain-damaged in those dimensions.

Worse than that, the Kindle is locked into the page-at-a-time model.  The iPad book readers also use that model, but it's a choice. The Instapaper reader doesn't have that limitation and let's scroll the text instead of "flipping" imaginary pages. Eventually, the other readers will support that, too.  They can do it any time they want.  Given its current display technology, the Kindle can't; it is not a choice.  So, it is locked into the old model of cut pages.

TweetBacks (Tweet this post)

Trackback(0)

TrackBack URI for this entry

Comments (3)


Show/hide comments
Agree with you on the iPad
0
I'm right there with you on this one Matt. This last trip that I took is the first major travel I've done carrying no books at all. I was a bit worried about it, but the iPad did really well. The only trade-off here is the longer battery life on the Kindle can be useful for long-haul flights (like, say, every single one from Australia to somewhere else! :-) ).

The other thing is that I don't like either the iPad or the Kindle for books that I read for my research - I still prefer paper there. At least for now. Overall, though, definitely interesting times in book-world.
Tim Kastelle , 05/28/2011 18:47:15 | url
re: Agree with you on the iPad
Matt Perez
Hey Tim,

About the research papers, how come you prefer paper for those? Is it because you make a lot of notes/scribbles/sketches on it?

If that's so, I agree with you. For highlights and plain text notes, I actually prefer to do it with the kindle software (because I can search through them online). But I can't draw and scribble freehand like I can on paper. And I do miss that :(
Matt Perez , 05/28/2011 19:16:06
research reading
0
It's not the notes so much, it's that when I'm reading things with referenced I flip back and forth between the text & the bibliography a lot, and I also go back and forth to tables and figures, which are both really hard to do still on e-readers. Also, when I'm writing, I still like to have a big stack of books and articles next to me that I want to reference - having them there physically reminds me to use them.
Tim Kastelle , 05/29/2011 00:11:03 | url

Write comment

smaller | bigger

busy